Skip to main content
Return to Website Magpies Softserve

Magpies Thanksgiving Softserve Pies

Thanksgiving dinner comes with plenty of opinions. Dessert doesn’t have to be one of them. Preorder your Softserve Pies now to get your favorite flavor before it’s gone, then choose your pickup day and location at checkout. Each pie serves 8 to 10 and keeps beautifully in the freezer for up to 2 weeks. Grab yours early and that’s one less thing on the list.

Salted Caramel Pumpkin Softserve Pie — whole pie
Turtle Softserve Pie — slice
Pistachio Baklava Softserve Pie — whole pie
Original Fried Softserve Pie — slice
Fudge Brownie Softserve Pie — slice
Salted Caramel Pumpkin Softserve Pie — slice
Gluten-Free Pumpkin Softserve Pie — whole pie
Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie — slice
Cookie Butter Softserve Pie — whole pie
Turtle Softserve Pie — whole pie
Original Fried Softserve Pie — whole pie
Pistachio Baklava Softserve Pie — slice
Gluten-Free Pumpkin Softserve Pie — slice
Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie — whole pie
Fudge Brownie Softserve Pie — whole pie
Cookie Butter Softserve Pie — slice
Thanksgiving Sampler — whole pie

Thanksgiving Softserve Pies

Salted Caramel Pumpkin Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Salted Caramel Pumpkin Softserve Pie — whole pie

Salted Caramel Pumpkin Softserve Pie

Vegan$49.95 per pie

Pumpkin Pie Softserve layered with brown sugar oats, topped with whipped cream, caramel & a dust of cinnamon in a graham cracker crust.

Gluten-Free Pumpkin Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Gluten-Free Pumpkin Softserve Pie — whole pie

Gluten-Free Pumpkin Softserve Pie

VeganGluten Free$54.95 per pie

Pumpkin Pie Softserve layered with brown sugar oats, topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle & cinnamon in a gluten-free graham cracker crust.

Turtle Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Turtle Softserve Pie — whole pie

Turtle Softserve Pie

VeganContains Nuts$49.95 per pie

Maple Brown Sugar Softserve layered with fudge & candied pecans, topped with whipped cream, caramel & candied pecans in a chocolate graham crust.

Cookie Butter Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Cookie Butter Softserve Pie — whole pie

Cookie Butter Softserve Pie

Vegan$49.95 per pie

Cookie Butter Softserve layered with Biscoff cookies, topped with caramel whipped cream, caramel drizzle & graham crumble in a graham cracker crust.

Pistachio Baklava Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Pistachio Baklava Softserve Pie — whole pie

Pistachio Baklava Softserve Pie

VeganContains Nuts$49.95 per pie

Pistachio Baklava Softserve layered with fudge, candied pistachios & almond pound cake, topped with whipped cream & pistachio crumble in a chocolate graham crust.

Fudge Brownie Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Fudge Brownie Softserve Pie — whole pie

Fudge Brownie Softserve Pie

Vegan$49.95 per pie

Brownie Softserve layered with fudge, brownies & chocolate crunchies, topped with chocolate whipped cream, brownies & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust.

Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie — whole pie

Cookies & Cream Softserve Pie

Vegan$49.95 per pie

Vanilla Bean Softserve layered with fudge & oreo cookies, topped w/oreo whipped cream & chocolate crumble in a chocolate graham crust

Original Fried Softserve Pie — slice showing the filling and crust
Original Fried Softserve Pie — whole pie

Original Fried Softserve Pie

Vegan$49.95 per pie

Corn Almond Softserve layered with fudge & honeycomb pieces, topped with whipped cream & fried cornflake streusel in a graham cracker crust

Thanksgiving Sampler whole pie with four flavors

Thanksgiving Sampler

VeganContains Nuts$54.95 per pie

The easiest choice for a table that wants to try four flavors.

  • Turtle Softserve Pie
  • Pistachio Baklava Softserve Pie
  • Fudge Brownie Softserve Pie
  • Cookie Butter Softserve Pie
Pink softserve in a Magpies cup beside yellow Magpies pint containers.

Round out the dessert table with a couple Softserve Pints, and give everyone a few more flavors to be thankful for.

Flavors change daily. See your shop’s current selection on Toast.